Magento vs Shopify Plus 2026: enterprise decision guide

TL;DR — In 2026 the choice between Magento (Adobe Commerce) and Shopify Plus is not about list price but about business model. Shopify Plus wins for pure D2C brands with < 1,000 SKUs and simple international rollout. Magento wins for B2B, > 5,000 SKUs, deep ERP integration and complex checkout.

Armah is Silver Solution Partner Hyvä and works with both platforms. Book an orientation call

Quick comparison 2026

Dimension	Magento / Adobe Commerce	Shopify Plus
Annual licence	0 (OSS) or $24k-140k	$2,500/mo + GMV fee
Hosting	$3-27k/year	included
B2C setup	$65-175k	$38-100k
B2B enterprise setup	$140-420k	$100-280k
Timeline	6-10 months	3-5 months
Performance OOTB	low (Luma) / high (Hyvä)	high
Custom checkout	full	limited (Checkout Extensions Plus)
Multi-store	unlimited	9 stores, then extra cost
ERP integration	mature	limited native, middleware needed
B2B advanced (RfQ, quotes, contract)	mature	basic (Shopify B2B)
Dev community	large, senior available	growing, junior-heavy

When to choose Shopify Plus

• Pure D2C brand with < 1,000 SKUs.
• Time-to-market critical: launch in 3-4 months.
• Small internal team: managed service crucial.
• Simple international rollout: 3-8 countries with standard VAT.
• SaaS marketing stack: Klaviyo, Recharge, Gorgias ready.

When to choose Magento

• Structured B2B: customer pricing, RfQ, contract orders.
• Large catalogs > 5,000 SKUs with PIM.
• Deep ERP integration: SAP, Oracle, Dynamics 365 bidirectional.
• Custom checkout: split payment, B2B flows, industry compliance.
• Multi-brand multi-store: 3+ storefronts with different catalogs.
• Product configurators: automotive, industrial, furniture, packaging.

The "Magento is slow" myth

Magento with default Luma theme has LCP ~4.2s in 2026. But Magento + Hyvä delivers LCP < 1.5s and Lighthouse mobile > 90 — matching or beating Shopify Plus.

3-year TCO example

For B2C with $9M GMV, 500 SKUs, 4 EU countries:

Item	Magento OSS + Hyvä	Adobe Commerce	Shopify Plus
License 3 years	0 + ~$3.5k Hyvä	~$220k	~$120k
Setup	$100k	$135k	$80k
Hosting 3 years	$17k	0 (included)	0 (included)
Maintenance 3 years	$200k	$240k	$145k
Transaction fees	0	0	~$45k
Total 3 years	~$320k	~$595k	~$390k

Magento OSS + Hyvä = lowest TCO for B2C mid-market.

See also: Magento Agency Europe · Magento Agency London · Hyvä vs Luma.

FAQ

Is Magento dead? Should I migrate to Shopify?

No. Adobe Commerce and OSS have roadmap through 2028+, active community, growing Hyvä ecosystem. Migration only makes sense if business model changed radically.

Does Shopify Plus support B2B like Magento?

Shopify B2B (2022, matured 2024-25) covers simple B2B. Not covered: RfQ workflow, per-customer catalogs, deep ERP, split payment, multi-step approval.

What does Shopify Plus really cost for a $12M GMV brand?

Base $2,500/mo up to $800k/mo GMV, then 0.25%. With $12M/year ~$35k/year license. Plus SaaS apps $18-45k, custom theme + ERP $80-140k. First year total: $150-230k.

Does Hyvä beat Shopify on performance?

On mobile LCP and Lighthouse: yes, on par. On TTFB Shopify wins (global CDN).

Adobe Commerce or Open Source in 2026?

Adobe Commerce worthwhile above $12M GMV with native B2B and MSI Enterprise. Below, OSS + Amasty + Hyvä covers 90% at 40-50% lower TCO.

Can a Magento agency also handle Shopify Plus?

The best ones: yes. 60% of skills are shared (SEO, performance, PIM, tracking).

---

Book an orientation call · Contact

BOFU — related guides

Dig deeper with city guides and head-to-head comparisons:

• 🎯 Magento agency across Europe
• ⚖️ Hyvä vs Luma real performance
• 📍 Magento agency London
• 📍 Magento agency Manchester
• 📍 Magento agency Dublin